While Athens Greece was prospering, China was suffering. Also in this document it shows how many people were in each class. One of the differences Athens and Han China shared were there forms of government.
Although these civilizations emerged nearly one thousand years apart, they had unique economic classes, had various forms of governance, and their philosophies were completely different.
During this period, Confucius lived and taught. This document is not resourceful if you wanted to compare the size of Athens and Han because the maps are two different sides. Confucius also believed that people should support their family, whether they broke the law or not. Chinese philosophers believed that the individual was not as important as the kingdom was as a whole, whereas Greek philosophers consider the individuals as a crucial part of society.
This would allow the reader to know what a Chinese philosopher would think about his place in society if he was questioned in what he believes in Document 9. The population distribution of Han China portrayed in Document 3 shows that there were only a few appointed officials along with the emperor, around thirteen times more educated bureaucrats, ten times as many aristocracies as bureaucrats, around 58, farmers, only 50, merchants, and 5, mean people.
Han China however does not look at an individual like the Greeks, but instead as a small piece in the vast kingdom. Aristotle believed that in learning those crafts, there would have been no difference between slave and master.
It is easier to be a democracy with a smaller population than a larger one. Documents 2 and 3 show two excerpts from philosophers in both Classical Athens and Han China that agreed on class distinctions.
In document 2, the Athenian philosopher Aristotle believed that those born into a higher status should not learn the trades of the lower classes.
In spite of Han China and Athens Greece, they were two major empires that both ruled around the same time frame. Third, the Han and Greek civilizations displayed numerous and unique economic classes that were different from each other. Aristotle believes this because he is a high class citizen and he does not want to change his class.
The Greek Discus Thrower portrayed in Document 11, is depicting the view that the individual is the main focus of the society in which one resides. There is no document that accurately portrays the feelings of a slave on class distinctions.
Although in Document 6, the way anyone is in government is chosen by the heavens. As shown in Document 7, the Han dynasty stresses a strong central government with many appointed governors to each district its dynasty possesses.
These maps are a biased point of view though because it has the Han Empire map enlarged so it makes the map of Athens look smaller, but also on the map of Athens in the bottom corner it has an enlarged box of Attica.
There is no document that portrays the take of a Greek philosopher simply on where an individual stands in the Greek state. Confucius believes this because he has his own ideals that are separate from the government and as long as people are doing the right thing they are a part of the government.
However, the Athenian government was based on the people, so they basically governed themselves Document 5. In document 4, Pericles describes the Athenian form of democracy and a few of their laws.
Confucius believed that as long as an individual is a friendly and supportive then he is taking part of government.
This type of government was effective because the central government was further enhanced by delegation of different areas. As shown in Document 12, the human is miniscule to the landscape around him, showing that the human is only a tiny piece in the civilization.
Athens focused on the rights of the individual whereas Han China preferred dominance that used an imperialist approach. Socrates was thrown into prison because he was charged for not believing in the gods that everyone believed, introducing other gods, and corrupting the youth. Another difference Athens and Han China both had were population.
However, the reason for this difference in political beliefs can be based on the difference of population. In document one it shows two maps, one of Athens, and one of the Han Empire. The Greek civilization had developed a new form of government; democracy that contrasted from the bureaucracy in Han China.
Athens, located in Attica was rather small surprisingly, smaller then Rhode Island. Despite these differences, both China and Athens believed there should be class distinctions between slaves and elite due to the differences in labor. As shown in Document 2, there were as many free male citizens as free male non-citizens and about as many free females as slaves.
We will write a custom essay sample on Athens vs Han China Dbq or any similar topic only for you We will write a custom essay sample on Athens vs Han China Dbq or any similar topic only for you Order now It would have been helpful to have the maps the same size, also they could have showed the populations in the areas and where most people lived and where they traveled.10/17/12 DBQ Athens vs Han China In the 5th century BCE Sparta and Athens constantly battled for 27 years for the number one spot in Greece.
Despite being at war for such a long time, Athens made their culture most memorable in our world's history. Han China however does not look at an individual like the Greeks, but instead as a small piece in the vast kingdom. We will write a custom essay sample on Han and Greek Dbq specifically for you for only $ $/page.
10/17/12 DBQ Athens vs Han China In the 5th century BCE Sparta and Athens constantly battled for 27 years for the number one spot in Greece.
Despite being at war for such a long time, Athens made their culture most memorable in our world’s history. Classical Athens and Han China Your task Compare these 2 civilizations while they were at their best. How were they different?
When historians talk about "Classical Athens," they mean the period of time during which Athens, a city-state in Greece, was at its BEST. DBQ? As you write, you will be deciding - HOW GREAT WERE THE. DBQ The ancient societies of Greece and China each produced a civilization remarkable for its time.
Although these civilizations emerged nearly one thousand years apart, their philosophies were completely different, had various forms of governance, and had unique economic classes. First, the thoughts of the numerous Greek philosophers were absolutely different from those of the [ ].
Which was more awesome: Classical Athens or Han China? Both of them are famous ancient civilizations. Classical Athens was a small city-state in Greece, on the Mediterranean Sea.
It was at its height in the 5th century BCE. Han China, on the other hand, was .Download